Learning objectives
By the end of the lesson, learners should be able to:
- apply control, secure possession, and voluntary release to a catch decision;
- explain the transfer provision in the 2026 MLB Catch definition (printed page 148);
- list the four conditions required for an infield fly;
- recognise that ordinary effort—not grass, position, or the eventual fielder—controls the call; and
- state that an infield fly leaves the ball live and does not force runners to advance.
Distinguish catch status from infield-fly eligibility
A catch and an infield fly answer different questions. One asks what the fielder controlled; the other protects runners from a routine-drop double play. The numbered tests organise the lesson; they do not prescribe the order of umpire calls.
Was it a catch?
- Secure possession in a hand or glove
- Firmly held—not trapped against clothing
- Complete control of the ball
- A voluntary and intentional release
2026 MLB Catch definition, page 148: after the fielder establishes complete control, opening the glove to make a transfer can show voluntary release. Control in the throwing hand is not required.
Was it an infield fly?
- 1A fair fly—not a line drive or attempted bunt
- 2Runners on first and second, or bases loaded
- 3Fewer than two outs
- 4An infielder can catch it with ordinary effort
The umpire declares an infield fly immediately when it becomes apparent that the batted ball qualifies, before any completed catch. The batter is out, the ball stays live, and runners may advance at their own risk. See the 2026 MLB Infield Fly definition, printed page 154.
Six terms learners need
- Catch
- Secure possession in a hand or glove, firmly held, with complete control and a voluntary release.
- Transfer
- The fielder’s act of moving the controlled ball from the glove toward the throwing hand. See the transfer provision in the 2026 MLB Catch definition, printed page 148.
- Ordinary effort
- The effort a fielder of average skill at that position in that league should exhibit on a play.
- Infield fly
- A qualifying fair fly that an infielder can catch with ordinary effort in the required runner-and-out situation.
- Retouch
- Returning to or remaining on the original base until a caught fly is first touched before advancing.
- “If fair”
- The umpire’s added declaration for a possible infield fly near a foul line; it applies only if the ball becomes fair.
Teaching sequence
- 0–6
Define the moment
Ask when a catch becomes complete: first glove contact, secure control, transfer, or umpire signal? Use responses to introduce control and voluntary release.
- 6–14
Test catch or no catch
Mime a clean catch and transfer, then a collision-and-drop. Learners identify the fact that changes the ruling.
- 14–22
Build the four-condition gate
Display the infield-fly checklist. Change one fact at a time: outs, occupied bases, type of hit, and ordinary effort.
- 22–35
Make the calls
Learners complete all eight situations. Require a ruling and the decisive condition, not a guess from where the ball landed.
- 35–40
Compare consequences
Use the three-part outcome strip. Ask learners to explain what the runners may or must do after each result.
Learner sheet: control, conditions, consequence
For each play, decide the ruling and identify the fact that decides it. These situations use Major League Baseball’s 2026 Official Baseball Rules for MLB competition. Youth, school, amateur, and local competitions may use different rules; check the applicable code. R1 means a runner on first base, R2 a runner on second base, and R3 a runner on third base.
- For a possible catch, test secure control and voluntary release.
- For a possible infield fly, check all four conditions: a fair fly other than a line drive or attempted bunt; runners on first and second, or bases loaded; fewer than two outs; and a ball an infielder can catch with ordinary effort.
- Then decide what happens to the batter, ball, and runners.
- 1
The transfer drop
Catch testThe outfielder securely controls a fly ball, takes two normal steps, then deliberately opens the glove to transfer the ball. The ball drops before reaching the throwing hand.
Catch or no catch?
RulingDecisive fact - 2
Contact with the wall
Catch testAn outfielder gloves a fly ball, immediately collides with the wall, falls, and loses the ball. The fielder never demonstrates complete control before the collision.
Catch or no catch?
RulingDecisive fact - 3
The team juggle
Catch testA pop fly tips off the second baseman’s glove, then the shortstop’s glove, before the first baseman secures it above the ground and voluntarily takes it from the glove.
Can this be a catch?
RulingDecisive fact - 4
Another person in between
Catch testA fly ball touches an outfielder’s glove, then strikes an offensive runner, and is finally caught by another fielder before reaching the ground.
Does the final possession complete a catch?
RulingDecisive fact - 5
Shallow outfield grass
1 outR1R2Third base emptyA high fair fly descends on shallow outfield grass. The shortstop could catch it with ordinary effort, but the centre fielder moves in and catches it.
Can the umpire correctly call an infield fly? If it is declared, explain what happens to the batter, ball, and runners when the ball is caught. What would change if it instead dropped untouched and remained fair?
RulingDecisive fact - 6
Two outs
2 outR1R2R3The batter hits a high fair pop that the shortstop could catch with ordinary effort. The ball drops untouched.
Is the batter automatically out under the infield fly rule?
RulingDecisive fact - 7
Only first occupied
0 outR1Second base emptyThird base emptyThe batter hits a routine fair pop directly above the second baseman. The fielder intentionally lets it fall untouched.
Does the infield fly rule apply?
RulingDecisive fact - 8
“Infield fly, if fair”
1 outR1R2Third base emptyNear the first-base line, the umpire declares “Infield fly, if fair.” The untouched ball lands in foul territory before first base and remains foul.
Is the batter out under the infield fly rule?
RulingDecisive fact
Answer key and reasoning
Look for the exact element of the Catch or Infield Fly definition that controls each result.
Catch.
The fielder had complete control and then voluntarily and intentionally opened the glove to transfer the ball. Under the clarified 2026 definition, possession in the throwing hand is not required. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Catch, printed page 148, transfer provision; Summary of Rule Changes, page vi.
No catch.
A fielder who drops the ball because of a collision or fall has not made a catch if complete control and voluntary release were not established first. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Catch, printed page 148, collision-and-fall provision.
Yes, it is a catch.
The first fielder need not be the one who completes the catch. The ball may be juggled by multiple fielders as long as it does not touch the ground and one fielder eventually establishes the required control and release. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Catch, printed page 148, multiple-fielder juggling provision.
No catch.
A ball that first touches a fielder, then touches an offensive player or umpire, is not a catch when another fielder subsequently secures it. Other rules may still govern the ball striking the runner. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Catch, printed page 148, intervening offensive-player or umpire contact.
Yes, the infield fly call can be correct.
The grass and the identity of the eventual catcher are not controlling. An infielder could catch the qualifying fair fly with ordinary effort, with first and second occupied and fewer than two outs. The batter is out and the ball remains live. When caught, runners must satisfy the retouch requirement; they may leave their original bases from the first fielder’s touch. If it drops untouched and remains fair, no catch-based retouch is required. In either case, runners are not forced to advance and may advance at their own risk. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Infield Fly and its Comment, printed pages 154–155; Catch, page 148; Rule 5.09(a)(5).
No infield fly; the ball remains live.
The rule requires fewer than two outs. With two outs, the dropped fair ball is played normally and the force remains. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Infield Fly, printed page 154, fewer-than-two-outs condition.
No infield fly.
The rule requires runners on first and second, or bases loaded. A runner on first alone is not enough. Rule 5.09(a)(12), Approved Ruling, excludes an untouched drop from its batter-out ruling unless the infield fly rule applies. Neither provision retires the batter here. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Infield Fly, printed page 154; Rule 5.09(a)(12) and its Approved Ruling, printed page 44.
No; it is a foul ball.
The declaration near the line was conditional. Because the ball became and remained foul, the infield fly ruling does not retire the batter. Rule: 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules, Definitions of Terms, Infield Fly, printed page 154, conditional declaration and foul-ball provisions.
Push the reasoning one step further
- Why does the Catch definition need both control and a voluntary release?
- In situation 5, what must runners do if the ball is caught? What if it drops? Teacher guidance: require learners to distinguish retouching on a catch from an untouched fair drop, which needs no catch-based retouch. In both cases the infield fly retires the batter, leaves the ball live, and removes the force to advance. Use answer 5’s rule locators.
- Why is the infield fly rule based on ordinary effort rather than a painted field boundary?
- How does declaring the batter out remove the cheap double-play opportunity?
Rule basis and further reading
This material paraphrases the rules for teaching; it does not replace the official wording.
- 2026 MLB Official Baseball RulesThe definitions of Catch, Infield Fly, Ordinary Effort, and Rule 5.09 governing outs.
- MLB: Infield FlyMLB’s explanatory glossary of infield-fly conditions and live-ball consequences; no edition is established for this glossary. The governing lesson source is the 2026 MLB Official Baseball Rules.
- Little League: Infield Fly FAQsA useful comparison for youth contexts and ordinary effort.