Authority, edition and competition scope
This explanation uses World Rugby’s live online Laws 8, 12 and 21, checked on 14 November 2026, for standard 15-a-side rugby union. The live chapters do not specify a numbered print edition. World Rugby states that its July 2026 updates apply to new competitions/events starting after 1 July; competitions already underway must confirm implementation with their union. A particular competition’s adoption remains unverified here. See the World Rugby implementation notice.
The probable-try test
A penalty try requires opposing foul play that prevents a probable try, including a probable try in a better scoring position. A mere scoring possibility is insufficient. As a practical reading of the test, ask what probably would have happened without the foul play; proximity to the line alone does not answer that question. World Rugby Law 8.3.
Location, points and player sanction
The award is between the posts: seven points, with no conversion. Law 8.3 sets no distance-from-the-line threshold for the offence; the deciding condition is its prevention of the probable score or better position. The guilty player must receive a caution and yellow card, or be sent off. A verbal warning alone does not satisfy this provision. World Rugby Laws 8.1(c) and 8.3.
For wider disciplinary coverage, see sin-bin and red-card rules.
How play restarts
When play resumes after the score, the team that conceded takes a drop kick on or behind the centre of halfway. This is the standard 15-a-side restart after a score. World Rugby Laws 12.1 and 12.4.
See kick-offs and restarts for positioning and kick requirements, and match timing for end-of-period situations.
How this differs from a grounding decision
Ordinary grounding decisions establish whether the ball was grounded correctly in in-goal. Holding the ball and touching it to the ground, or applying downward pressure with permitted body parts, are recognised grounding methods. Picking the ball up is not grounding it. A legally held-up ball and doubt about which team grounded first have their own restart provisions. World Rugby Laws 21.1–21.3 and 21.16–21.17.
A penalty try instead addresses a probable score prevented by foul play; completed grounding is not its prerequisite. Uncertain grounding alone does not establish that test. World Rugby Law 8.3.
For the detailed grounding and held-up decisions, see grounding, tries and held-up balls.
Primary governing-body sources
- World Rugby, Law 8: Scoring — 8.1(c) and 8.3; live text checked 14 November 2026.
- World Rugby, Law 12: Kick-off and restart kicks — 12.1 and 12.4; live text checked 14 November 2026.
- World Rugby, Law 21: In-goal — grounding, held-up balls and doubt about grounding; live text checked 14 November 2026.
- World Rugby, 2026-07 Law updates — implementation timing and union confirmation for ongoing competitions.